Friday, September 23, 2011

Wrongful birth / life

Introduction

Development of technology in the field of medicine has been so rapid that ethics, public policy and the law have struggled to keep pace. In an earlier English case, Thake v Maurie[1] ( ‘Thake’) where plaintiff sought to recover damages in several aspects, for example, pain of suffering of labour, present and future economic loss which includes cost of upbringing of a child. This research paper will only focus on cost of upbringing a child. In this particular case, the parents were successful in claiming the damages until its seventeenth birthday.

The case decision was not followed by the later English case, McFarlene v Tayside Health Board[2]. The court disallowed the recovery of cost of maintenance of a child on the basis of legal policies. Until the recent Australian case, Cattanach v Melchior[3], the court stepped out from policy considerations, considered from a new perspective of reality and awarded the recovery of cost of bringing up of a child.

The discussion on whether cost of child’s upbringing should be recovered will be considered and mainly focus on the following issues along with case precedents, social, legal and public policy considerations.

1) The purpose of recovering cost of child’s maintenance

2) Is having a child a burden or blessing

3) Should liability of doctor be extended to bear the child’s maintenance cost?

1) The purpose of recovering cost of child’s maintenance

The ordinary principle of negligence requires loss as a result of injury to be proven in order to claim for damages. It is vital to know about the subject matter of the claim of damage, that is, the cost of child’s maintenance but not the birth of a child. Of course, to claim that the birth of the child is a loss can be morally offensive as a child is not a commodity[4] and human life is unique which is impossible to value it in monetary form.

Justice Kirby sees the cost of upbringing of a child as a consequential loss upon the physical injury to the mother and thus it should be allowed to recover. Whether or not pregnancy is a physical injury is not the focus. The focus today is the aim of recovering the damages. It is not of usual compensatory nature but it is a kind of assistance to the life of the existing child whose parents are financially incapable to provide. The doctor who has been negligent in carrying out medical procedure pays the damages in pursuant to his legal and moral obligation. As compared to damages, it is reasonably ascertainable as it is a financial calculation and objectively necessary[5].

However, there is an issue of quantifying the cost in case of the disabled child. In two different claims, one wrongful birth, how do courts assess the cost of special need and care in the process of bringing up the child, and then other one wrongful life which is brought by the child, how do courts assess the damages by comparing with the non-existence of the child if negligence has not been incurred[6].

2) Is having a child a burden or blessing?

Starting with Udale, one of the reasons of why court refused to allow the recovery of child maintenance cost is, on the basis of public policy, having a healthy child is inarguably a blessing[7]. The process of nurturing the child and existence of parenthood is an enjoyment and this will offset the financial burden of raising up the child[8].However, that would not be the case when the pregnancy results in an unwanted consequence. For example in Parkinson v St James and Seacroft University NHS Trust[9] and Rees v Darlington Memorial Hospital NHS Trust 2004[10], having a child is likely to be a burden to the parents.

Nowadays, even if the child is born healthy by an able parent, the fact that having a child is a blessing is no longer practical in real life. In fact, the word ‘blessing’ is an overstatement to parents who do not want the pregnancy. It cannot be possibly regarded as a blessing when someone specifically undertakes sterilization procedure to avoid ‘benefit’ of parenthood.[11] In Thake, Peter Pain J pointed out the availability of abortion and sterilization in current society which implies that it is not necessary desirable when a child is conceived. Especially for families who were on a restricted income and decides to go birth control, having a child is not a blessing at all, but a burden.

Opinion diverged among member of the society, some might think it is a benefit, some might think it is a burden. In McFalene, Haje J suggested ‘deemed equilibrium’ between the burden incurred of having a child and the benefit of having a child, with each cancelling out the other, so the cost of child rearing is not recoverable. Unless one thing that tipped the balance, for example in Parkinson and Rees where one side is burdened with additional expense along with the special disability the damage is recoverable[12]. By the way, they are two different issues that do not engage in a balancing equation. To look into the idea of having a child in precision, enjoyment of parenting might be reduced due to economic realities in the future. Perhaps it is easier to calculate the cost of upkeeping ( economic loss) as a loss than as a benefit ( non- economic gain). Yet, the value of benefit of having a child could not be calculated and thus there is no way the claim can be based on a cost which outweighs the benefit[13].

In Cattanach, the majority of the court chooses to award damages of the cost of upbringing of a child on the basis of burden of legal and moral responsibilities incurred and financially not be able to bear. For the sake of maintain the child, there must be a solution to solve the problem so that ‘the child has a belly to be filled and a body to be clothed’[14]. This is the issue of reality. In assuring plaintiff with an amount of money as reparation, the court emphasized that they did not try to set aside the importance of the value of life and the parenthood.

3) Should liability of doctor be extended to bear the child’s maintenance cost?

The relationship between a doctor and patient give rise to a duty of care owed to the patient. It is reasonable foreseeable[15] that harm would have occurred had the doctor been negligent. In the case of wrongful life and wrongful birth, the parent would not have conceived the child but for the doctor’s failure in advising on the risk or carrying out operation with due care and skill.

However, Thake concludes that there is an inherent risk in every operation. By allowing the doctor to bear all the cost of rearing child which is a huge expense has in fact gone beyond the doctor’s culpability[16]. The responsibility of raising up the child should also be shared by the parents. It does not seem to be right seeing the parents are relieved of financial burden to the child rearing and allow the other to take over the onus. Lord Millet in McFarlene considered it as a price of parenthood.

Considering the consequence of extending liability of doctor, it is worrying that this policy will encourage doctors to do abortion for the sake of avoiding liability[17]. This is not a healthy social trend if it is adopted.

Conclusion

Although there are ethical issues on the sanctity of life which should not be valued in money, the argument of awarding damages of cost of maintenance should not just cease at this point. The child was born and the reality that he or she is going to face is more unexpected and difficult than assessing the damages. By awarding the cost of maintenance does not mean to impose an economic value on the child but it is a better respond to the call of living for help in bearing the burden of their affliction.



Friday, April 15, 2011


1、没有伞的孩子必须努力奔跑! 2、你不勇敢,没人替你坚强。 3、如果心胸不似海,又怎能有海一样的事业。 4、只有经历过地狱般的折磨,才有征服天堂的力量。只有流过血的手指才能弹出世间的绝唱。 5、流过泪的眼睛更明亮,滴过血的心灵更坚强! 6、志在山顶的人,不会贪念山腰的风景… 7、.前有阻碍,奋力把它冲开,运用炙热的激情,转动心中的期待,血在澎湃,吃苦流汗算什么。 8、对的,坚持;错的,放弃! 9、.宁愿跑起来被拌倒无数次,也不愿规规矩矩走一辈子。就算跌倒也要豪迈的笑 。 10、不要生气要争气,不要看破要突破,不要嫉妒要欣赏,不要托延要积极,不要心动要行动。 11、.没有不老的誓言,没有不变的承诺,踏上旅途,义无反顾! 12、态度决定一切,实力捍卫尊严!人要经得起诱惑耐得住寂寞! 13、你可以很有个性,但某些时候请收敛。 14、.自己选择的路、跪着也要把它走完



Sunday, February 27, 2011

Mark Zuckerberg Vs Julian Assange

Like two of our runners-up this year, Julian Assange and the Tea Party, Mark Zuckerberg doesn't have a whole lot of veneration for traditional authority. In a sense, Zuckerberg and Assange are two sides of the same coin. Both express a desire for openness and transparency. While Assange attacks big institutions and governments through involuntary transparency with the goal of disempowering them, Zuckerberg enables individuals to voluntarily share information with the idea of empowering them. Assange sees the world as filled with real and imagined enemies; Zuckerberg sees the world as filled with potential friends. Both have a certain disdain for privacy: in Assange's case because he feels it allows malevolence to flourish; in Zuckerberg's case because he sees it as a cultural anachronism, an impediment to a more efficient and open connection between people.

Thursday, January 27, 2011

Celine Dion - Goodbye's The Saddest Word - Lyrics


Now I know
There is no other
Love like a mother's love for her child

And I know
A love so complete
Someday must leave
Must say goodbye

Goodbye's the saddest word I'll ever hear
Goodbye's the last time I will hold you near
Someday you'll say that word and I will cry
It'll break my heart to hear you say goodbye

Monday, January 17, 2011

Barry Schwartz--The loss of wisdom

Why is it that societies of great abundance — where individuals are offered more freedom and choice (personal, professional, material) than ever before — are now witnessing a near-epidemic of depression? This is the core question of the whole discussion.

Barry Schwartz makes a passionate call for "practical wisdom" as an antidote to a society gone mad with bureaucracy. He argues powerfully that rules often fail us, incentives often backfire, and practical, everyday wisdom will help rebuild our world.

Barry Schwartz, a psychologist, studies the link between economics and psychology, offering startling insights into modern life. Lately, working with Ken Sharpe, he's studying wisdom, something that has lost among ppl nowadays.Between Incentive and rules, the answer to this question is a paradox, it would never be proportional.There are a few issues being talked here.
1. Practical wisdom
It is a combination of moral will and moral skill.
Brilliance is rampant. There are people who are brilliant but lack of wisdom. Without wisdom, brilliance is not enough. In this cutting edge environment, we are bound by rules and regulation. Moral rules is chipped away by the rules that deprives us of the opportunity to improvise and learn.
2. Is two-reason better than one ?
Not necessary. Years back in 2005 Switzerland, two respective community are asked and requested for a nuclear dump. The community A, abt 50% agrees to the project as it has to be dumped in somewhere else and this is considered as a citizen's responsibility to agree on this motion.
The community B, however ware requested to do the same with a slightly different question? " Everyone is paid for the salary, Would u allow the nuclear dump to be placed in ur community? There are supposedly 2 reasons, responsibility and getting paid to support the motion. But the result turns out only 25% of residents agree.
Is not how many reasons u need to do one thing? It is which reason that serves ur interest the best.
3. Incentive
People need living. Any incentive system can be subverted by a bad will. But, excessive reliance on incentive demoralizes your professional activity in two senses: It makes the ppl engaged in the activity to lose morale and It makes the activity itself to lose morality.
Barack Obama, before inaugurated, he mentioned Ask not is it profitable, but is it right?

Everyone is inspired by moral hero.
With the right will, do the right thing, in the right way and this is practical wisdom.

Sunday, January 16, 2011

Courage Is - The Strange Familiar [Full Song]

Unveiled mist, as clear as crystal

Two days ago,
When i was back from sarawak,
the truth was out,
the outcome was more than complicated than we thought
but for God sake, we found the truth.

Three months of struggle and hardship
are all paid off,
it does not require 10 years like i presumed
maybe it is why truth is a timeless fact that is vulnerable to time
It has to be revealed at last

Tonnes of tears, sigh, anger and finally relief
consciously or unconsciously
this incident has turned me into an adult, telling me
be responsible, be mature, be brave, be alert
--I've learned that no matter what happens, or how bad it seems today, life does go on, and it will be better tomorrow
--'I've learned that you shouldn't go through life with a catcher's mitt on both hands; you need to be able to throw some things back...'
--'I've learned that whenever I decide something with an open heart, I usually make the right decision.'
--I've learned that people will forget what you said, people will forget what you did, but people will never forget how you made them feel.'


A best friend who i used to own
is now more than evil and dangerous that i think
Unable to open her heart
is the biggest weakness that will forever stumble her life journey
Lots of excuses and lies~
until she lost her way

Here, i got the answer for everything
forgiven those who should be
has been a victim for these three months
learned things through eye, heart and brain
swear will not fall into the same trap again...
hope will not encounter this again
If yes, no choice, i will still get up very fast and face it intelligently and patiently

Life does go on~
and tomorrow will be better :)
I love being myself
I love my family who gave me forever supports when i was beaten down
Courage,
I have it, i own it, i possess it,
Come on!!! Cheer for life!!!
because
" Courage is when you are afraid, but u keep on moving anyways~"
" Courage is when you are in pain, but u keep on living anyways~"