Over days of trial for Rv Bob, over a long hard mind-struggling process, over millions of arguement. I passed a verdict of guilty to Mr BOB.
I admit that i hold justice firmly in my mind for whatever decision i made. The verdict i passed was claimed to be beyond expectation and unconvincing by a few of attending audiences. I think i main reason is the unprofessional way of delivering my judgement which has led to non-transparent and raised doubts. A lot of unconvincing prohibited words like possibly, highly likely and maybe were used by me which create the uncertain among audience. This is my fault and unprofessionalism.
Again, justice is always held in my eyes. In any criminal case, to convict the murderer, i have to prove the guilt act( actus reas) and guity mind( mens rea) of defendant. Besides the most difficult job here is to prove beyond all the reasonable doubt. KEY circumstatial question. 1) If all the evidences ( including direct and indirect) were pointing towards defendent, but there is a single or a 1/100 percent of doubt, guilty or not guilty? Evidences prove the actus rea and mens rea which is somewhat contradictory to the principle of beyond the resonable doubt. why i say is contracdictory? bcz no matter how hard to prove the two elements of guilt. A small percentage of doubt will make the defendent to accquit from the court. I puzzled. I doubted the justice system where justice should be determined. Then i think, if justice is defined in this way where a small doubt can discard a person's guilt, then it would be a lot of non- guilty cases. At the same time, i disagree with the existence of the statement, "it is better to let go of ten guilty person than convicting an innocent person". How on earth does this statement clarify justice?
This statement shows an over-protected/ biased/ unbalanced balance to the defendent, in which u could deny all the fact because of the doubt.
2. Afterall, i was thinking, no matter how, i have to make a judgement based on my own discretion. About the highest standard of proof, beyond the reasonable doubts, i believe that there is still a deficiency of knowledge to it as well as the complementary application. Since this is a high standard of proof, the court would define the doubt as a uncertain that cannot be explained based on the evidences. And it must be resonable in which in my case, r v bob, i question the doubts casted.
3. Come to this stage of thinking, i held an established actus rea and mens rea to claim guilty for the accused by proving the case beyond any reasonable doubt. There is no doubt in this case.
Since it exists in determination of guilt of defendent, i suddenly realized that importance of this standard. If this standard were to be held in the way that a 0.01 percent of doubt ( which is highly likely to be unreasonable) was taken into decision making, then there will be co criminal in he world because as claimed there is always a doubt in anything needless to say it is a murder. Because we are human being, we are easily doubted by any uncertain...but was it reasonable?
4. With the actus rea and men rea, added with no REASONable doubt, the defendent was found to be GUILTY.
Today, i'm a 19-year-old judge, with the limited legal knowledge and zero experience, i define my own meaning of " justice ".
No comments:
Post a Comment